The grey market is the sale of a brand's own products outside its authorised distribution channel: batches set aside for another country, another distributor or an institutional buyer end up on shelves in a market where they should not be sold. Because the product is not counterfeit, it cannot be told apart by its packaging, its 2D code or its contents. What shows it is in the wrong channel is a mark carrying the market it was allocated to, together with a record of where that mark was read. What the situation means legally is a separate question, assessed against the current legislation and case law.
How do the grey market, parallel imports and counterfeits differ?
The three terms are often mixed up, but each answers a different question.
| Who made the product? | Where is the problem? | Typical example | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Counterfeit | Someone other than the right holder | In the product itself | Imitation packaging, different contents |
| Diversion | The right holder | Where the product is sold | A batch allocated to one market sold in another |
| Parallel import | The right holder, or a third party with its consent | In how the product enters the country | A product put on the market abroad and brought in by someone other than the authorised importer |
Authentication standards draw the same line. According to EUIPO's anti-counterfeiting technology guide, ISO 22383:2020 lists preventing diversion as a purpose of authentication solutions in its own right, alongside anti-counterfeiting and preventing product fraud. ISO 22384:2020, which guides brand owners in setting up a protection plan, names the grey market among the types of fraud it covers, next to copying and refilling.
What does the grey market cost a brand?
Because the product is genuine, the damage is not obvious at first. In practice these problems come up:
- Territorial and pricing policy breaks down. A product released at one market's price competes with the authorised distributor in a market where the price is higher.
- Distributor relationships suffer. When the authorised distributor asks where the product in its territory came from, the brand has no concrete answer.
- The product's journey is unknown. Nobody knows how goods from outside the channel were transported and stored; in medicines, cosmetics and food that is a quality question as well.
- Labels and rules stop matching. A label prepared for another market may not meet the language and information rules of the country where it is sold.
- Complaints and service land in the wrong place. Warranty claims and complaints reach a distributor that never sold the product.
How does the law treat the grey market?
This section is not legal advice; for a specific case, the current text and case law should be reviewed with your legal team.
Article 152 of Türkiye's Industrial Property Law No. 6769 governs exhaustion of rights: once products protected by an industrial property right have been put on the market by the right holder or by third parties with its consent, acts relating to those products fall outside the scope of the right. The second paragraph of the same article makes an exception: the trademark owner may prevent third parties from using those products commercially after altering or impairing them.
These two paragraphs shape the task of a brand facing diversion. If the product is simply being sold in the wrong place, relying on the trademark right may not always be possible. Where the product has been repackaged, relabelled or impaired, the second paragraph comes into play. Either way, the first step is to show which channel the product belongs to and what has changed on it.
The contractual side of the channel has its own rules. Clauses that restrict distributors by territory or customer are subject to competition law and are assessed under the Turkish Competition Authority's Block Exemption Communiqué on Vertical Agreements (No. 2002/2). Which restrictions benefit from the exemption should be settled with your legal team before the contract is drafted.
Why don't customs stop genuine goods?
Protection of intellectual property rights at Turkish customs rests on Article 57 of the Customs Law and Articles 100 to 111 of the Customs Regulation. According to the Ministry of Trade, the right holder applies electronically through the "Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights Programme" on the Ministry's website, using the form in Annex 13 of the Customs Regulation. Besides the section describing counterfeit goods, the form has a separate section on the original goods ("Orijinal Eşya İle İlgili"). An accepted application provides protection for up to one year from the application date.
The same guidance states that border measures do not apply where goods produced with the right holder's consent are put through a customs procedure without that consent. In other words, customs will not stop genuine goods arriving through an unauthorised channel the way it stops counterfeits. Showing how the product left the channel remains the brand's job.
If the product is genuine, how do you know it is in the wrong channel?
Most clues used in the field are weak, because whoever diverts the product can remove them easily.
- Serial and batch numbers: They can be scratched off, covered with a sticker, or the product can be repackaged. Even when they survive, they show which distributor received the product only when matched against shipping records.
- Label language and packaging differences: These disappear when the product is repacked with a local label.
- Price and order anomalies: An unusually large order from one distributor raises suspicion but does not show where the goods went.
A sturdier approach is to write the channel onto the product itself and tie every reading to a record:
- Allocation: Before shipment, record which batch goes to which market or distributor.
- Mark: Apply a mark to the product that is invisible to the naked eye and can be distinguished only with a defined reader. Because the outer carton can be swapped, put the mark where possible on the product itself or on the inner packaging that stays with it as well.
- Reading points: Field team store visits, test purchases from marketplaces, returns intake and distributor warehouses.
- Record: Store every reading with the product, place, time, device and the person who made it.
- Pattern: One reading is an incident; unexpected readings repeating in the same region point to a channel problem.
We covered surface choice and marking carton and product separately in which signature goes on which surface, and deploying readers in the field in setting up verification for your field team.
What is the reading record good for?
Diversion often starts with a difficult conversation with a distributor. A brand holding only a photo cannot answer the objection that the product did not come from that distributor's channel. A record showing which product was read, on what date, in which region and by whom moves that conversation from assumption to data.
The same record can be used in internal audits and, where needed, in legal proceedings. How it is weighed in a dispute is for your legal team and the courts to decide on the facts of the case.
Frequently asked questions
Is a grey-market product counterfeit? No. The right holder made it; the problem is not the product but the channel it is sold through. If the product has been altered or repackaged, the assessment may change.
Will customs stop a genuine parallel-imported product? According to the Ministry of Trade, border measures do not apply to goods produced with the right holder's consent, even when they are put through a customs procedure without that consent.
Isn't a serial number enough to show the channel? It helps as long as it stays in place and is matched against shipping records. But it can be removed or covered, or the product repackaged. An invisible mark is not affected by those interventions.
Can I ban a distributor from selling into other territories by contract? Territorial and customer restrictions are subject to competition law. Which restrictions will hold should be decided with your legal team in light of Communiqué No. 2002/2 and current decisions of the Turkish Competition Board.
Where does Lumvex fit in this check?
Lumvex applies a luminescent signature, invisible to the naked eye and used only on your products, to your product or packaging during your existing printing, coating or varnishing step. When your field team, dealer or inspector holds the reader to the product, the answer comes on the spot and every reading is recorded with the product, place and person. Readings are compared by region and dealer, so a product scanned in a region where it should not be sold is noticed. Lumvex does not replace legal assessment, a customs application or contract drafting. See the solutions and how we work pages for detail.
Sources
- Industrial Property Law No. 6769 (mevzuat.gov.tr, in Turkish)
- Turkish Ministry of Trade, Intellectual Property Rights: Frequently Asked Questions (in Turkish)
- Turkish Competition Authority, Block Exemption Communiqué on Vertical Agreements (No. 2002/2, in Turkish)
- EUIPO Anti-Counterfeiting and Anti-Piracy Technology Guide: ISO standards
- EUIPO Anti-Counterfeiting and Anti-Piracy Technology Guide: ISO 22383:2020


